Skip to main content

The value of opinion!

Have just finished watching the review of the news on the Andrew Marr show, a political discussion show on BBC UK TV ... nothing out of the ordinary today except a comment that got me thinking.

One contributor to the show was the Editor of 'The Huffington Post' http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/ which currently has some 18k likes on their facebook page. At one point Andrew Marr was bemoaning the lack of real journalism and journalists in the press - to which she replied that at the HP there were only ~26 journalists but some 3000 bloggers whose opinions were included. The comment seemed to be expressing a desire for more facts and research rather than opinion.

I also watched the film 'Contagion' last night which included a character, played by Jude Law, who had some 12m followers on his blog post and who swayed public opinion in what transpired to be a very unhelpful way (Hope that is not a spoiler ... watch the film - quite good!)

Obviously Social Media has meant that many, myself included, have a potential platform to air opinion and thought - but is there a point at which this is not only unhelpful but becomes dangerously counter productive.

Take finance ... ultimately however good, well thought through, and well executed a Governments fiscal policy actually is if, in the opinion of the thousands of shareholders in the world, they are troubled they will start a run against a company, financial institution or even Country ... result is panic!

Definition of OPINION
  1. A view or judgment formed about something, not necessarily based on fact or knowledge.
  2. The beliefs or views of a large number or majority of people about a particular thing.
I love the space that the Internet provides to voice opinion but, like anything else it is best when based on sound reason, research and logic? Many people hold opinions because their friends do, or someone famous does, or ... "I don't want to be seen to be without an opinion so whose opinion can I follow?" Is that genuinely an opinion? Perhaps ... but is it helpful for the development of society to have such a potentially vast audience to communicate it?

As my two eldest children debated quite strongly the other day ... opinion v fact ... it was interesting to watch their arguments develop - with no conclusion of course!

I guess, over the years, my opinions have either been confirmed, swayed or eroded as I have built understanding and facts into them ... however good they might be - does having an opinion and a forum for expressing them bring greater responsibility for others in society ... or is that just my opinion?

Press on!

Comments

  1. AnonymousJune 22, 2012 at 11:00 AM

    Social studies seem to suggest that there is a critical mass in a population of apparently 24%. If 24% of the population believe something then the balance of the populatiopn will eventually agree with that opinion or whatever that something is within a short period of time.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Feel free to add comments or ask questions:

Popular posts from this blog

Thoughts from a previous incumbent ...

In reference to 2 Tim 1:7 "For God did not give us a spirit of timidity, but a spirit of p o wer, of love a nd of sel f-discipli ne."   Norman Grubb decl are d that; "We are set in our day and generation to be overcomers, not to sail through calm seas but to walk on storms, to replace need with supply, to transform aspiration into realization. The language of defeatism, fear, lack and weakness is not to be in our vocabulary. "Let us go up at once and possess it, for we are well able to overcome it. As for these giants, they are bread for us," we say with sturdy Caleb.  We are to act as the men of faith of old; we are to visualize our goal in clear outline; we are to take it for granted that we shall reach it, for we have both the commission and anointing of God?   We lay our plans ,build our organisations, produce our written and verbal pronouncements,  prayer our prayers, do our work, not as those who will fail and fall by the way, but...
2 comments
Read more

What is poverty?

I have been very exercised recently for a number of reasons; 1/ Extended conversations with my teenage children about Sex trafficking (Initiated by the recent LZ7 track!) 2/ The dialogue online concerning the relative merits of Kony2012 campaign. 3/ Spending a morning praying for Street Children in Senegal (Talibes) and Prostitutes in Cambodia. 4/ Recently listening to a Dr M Loyd-Jones podcast - in which he refers to the state of 'apostasy' that the Church had got itself into at the end of the 19th, beginning of the 20th Century, as it cared so much for social, justice and poverty issues that it ceased to preach the gospel. (His words of course!) Now, where do my kids find their place in the midst of all of this? Our discussion centred around how meaningful is it to download a track and feel justified that you are doing something about sex trafficking? Is that simply consumer activism ... would we be so concerned to spend our 69p if we weren't getting a download out ...
4 comments
Read more

Labels

Who are you? I have never been a great fan of labels when it comes to describing members of the body of Christ. eg. he is anglican, she is Baptist, they are Charismatic, etc. etc. I remember once causing a man to become increasingly hot under the collar when he asked me who I was? To which I replied I was a disciple (follower) of Jesus. He was meaning which Church did I attend (presumably so he could classify me and decide whether I was bona fide or not) and my answer did not bring him peace, but I refused to go any further.  Why? Because, as I said, I am not a great fan of labels, but also because for me there is a very important distinction between primarily identifying myself with Jesus and identifying myself with Church. Of course, I recognise that by becoming a follower of Jesus I become part of the body of Christ, but that can be very distinct from being a member of a Church. To me this is the crucial difference between vibrant faith and dusty religion.  ...
1 comment
Read more